Evaluating Thermal Properties in Greases: Ensuring Reliability in High-Temperature Applications

Greases play a critical role in protecting mechanical components under various operational conditions, particularly those involving high temperatures, loads, and extended service intervals. 

To ensure that greases function effectively in these environments, it is essential to understand their thermal properties and performance characteristics. 

Thermal properties testing for greases provide insights into their behavior when exposed to elevated temperatures, helping to predict performance, longevity, and failure mechanisms.

For reliability and lubrication engineers, especially those responsible for asset management and equipment maintenance, testing the thermal properties of greases is integral to determining the suitability of a lubricant for a specific application. 

Laboratory testing methods assess the grease’s resistance to high temperatures, oxidation, thermal stability, and evaporative loss—properties that ultimately influence machine reliability, bearing performance, and lubrication intervals.

This article delves into the key aspects of thermal properties testing for greases, exploring the most widely recognized test methods, the significance of results, and their implications for machinery lubrication professionals. 

We will also examine the challenges posed by thermal degradation and the factors influencing grease selection for high-temperature environments.

Understanding the Role of Greases in High-Temperature Applications

Greases are primarily composed of base oil, a thickener, and additives, each of which plays a role in defining its overall performance. 

The base oil provides the essential lubricating film, the thickener acts as a carrier for the oil, and the additives offer enhanced protection against wear, oxidation, and corrosion. 

In high-temperature applications, however, the thermal stability of the base oil and the thickener, as well as the ability of additives to withstand elevated temperatures, are critical to maintaining grease performance.

High temperatures can cause greases to soften, bleed oil, oxidize, or completely degrade, leading to compromised lubrication, increased wear, and eventual equipment failure. 

Understanding these failure modes is essential for selecting greases capable of withstanding the thermal demands of specific applications. This is where thermal properties testing becomes indispensable.

Key Thermal Properties of Greases

Thermal properties testing for greases evaluates how the lubricant performs under the stress of heat and oxidation. 

Among the most critical properties tested are: Dropping Point, Oxidation Stability, High-Temperature Life and Evaporation Loss.

These properties help engineers understand how greases will perform over time and in the presence of high temperatures, which directly impacts the reliability and maintenance intervals of machinery.

Dropping Point: The Temperature Limit

One of the fundamental thermal properties of grease is its dropping point, which represents the temperature at which the grease transitions from a semi-solid to a liquid state. 

The ASTM D2265 and ASTM D566 standards are commonly used to determine this property, with ASTM D2265 being the preferred method for high-temperature greases due to its ability to measure dropping points up to 400°C.

In this test, the grease is heated gradually until a drop of liquid oil emerges from the sample. This temperature is considered as the dropping point. While this test gives an indication of the upper temperature limit of grease, it does not necessarily correlate with actual service temperatures. 

The dropping point is more of a threshold at which the thickener structure breaks down, and it should not be confused with the operational temperature range of the grease. 

However, it is a useful indicator for selecting greases that will not liquefy prematurely in high-temperature applications such as in ovens, kilns, or foundry equipment.

Oxidation Stability: Resistance to Chemical Degradation

Oxidation is a major cause of grease degradation at high temperatures. When exposed to air, the base oil in the grease can react with oxygen, forming acidic byproducts that can lead to increased viscosity, the formation of varnish or sludge, and eventual hardening of the grease. 

Oxidation stability testing evaluates a grease's resistance to this degradation mechanism, helping to predict its longevity in high-temperature applications.

The most widely accepted test method for oxidation stability is ASTM D942, which measures the pressure drop in a sealed oxygen chamber as the grease is subjected to elevated temperatures, typically around 99°C (210°F), over an extended period. 

The test provides a direct measure of the grease's ability to resist oxidation, with smaller pressure drops indicating better oxidation resistance.

For more severe conditions, the ASTM D5483 test method can be employed. This method involves testing greases at higher temperatures (150°C) and in the presence of a catalytic metal such as copper, which accelerates the oxidation process. 

Results from this test are more applicable to modern industrial applications, such as those involving high-speed bearings, electric motors, or automotive systems.

High-Temperature Life: Prolonged Exposure and Service Life

The high-temperature life of a grease is one of the most crucial indicators of its long-term performance in applications subjected to sustained elevated temperatures. 

Unlike the dropping point or short-term oxidation stability tests, high-temperature life testing assesses how long the grease can remain effective under continuous thermal stress.

The ASTM D3336 test method is the most widely used for evaluating the high-temperature life of greases. In this test, a sample of grease is applied to a bearing, which is then operated at a set temperature (typically between 120°C and 180°C) and a constant speed. 

The test continues until the bearing torque increases significantly or the grease fails to lubricate effectively, marking the end of the grease's high-temperature life.

Results from this test are critical for applications involving prolonged exposure to heat, such as in electric motor bearings, fans, or industrial ovens. 

High-temperature life tests provide a realistic assessment of how long a grease will perform in the field, making it a valuable tool for reliability engineers when selecting greases for critical equipment.

Evaporation Loss: Volatility and Oil Retention

As temperatures increase, the lighter fractions of the base oil in a grease can evaporate, leading to oil depletion and reduced lubrication effectiveness. 

Evaporation loss is a particularly important factor in high-temperature applications where grease is exposed to elevated temperatures for long periods.

ASTM D2595 is the standard method for measuring the evaporation loss of greases. In this test, a sample of grease is placed in a cup and heated to a specified temperature (often 100°C, 150°C, or 204°C) for 22 hours. 

The weight loss due to evaporation is measured and expressed as a percentage. Greases with lower evaporation losses are better suited for high-temperature applications, as they are less likely to suffer from oil depletion, ensuring sustained lubrication over time.

Evaporation loss testing is particularly relevant for greases used in high-speed bearings, industrial gearboxes, and other equipment where oil retention is crucial for maintaining film thickness and preventing wear. 

In severe cases of evaporation loss, equipment may require more frequent relubrication, or the grease may need to be replaced entirely.

The Impact of Additives on Thermal Properties

The thermal properties of grease are heavily influenced by the additives used in its formulation. Additives such as antioxidants, extreme pressure (EP) agents, and viscosity index (VI) improvers are essential for enhancing a grease's ability to withstand high temperatures and mechanical stresses.

Antioxidants, for example, play a critical role in improving oxidation stability. They work by neutralizing free radicals formed during the oxidation process, thereby extending the grease's service life. 

EP additives, which form protective films on metal surfaces, can help reduce wear at high temperatures, while VI improvers enhance the grease's ability to maintain its viscosity across a wide temperature range.

Laboratory testing of grease additives is crucial to understanding their effects on thermal properties. For instance, EP performance is often tested using ASTM D2596, which measures the load-carrying capacity of greases under high-pressure conditions.

Challenges in High-Temperature Grease Applications

Selecting the right grease for high-temperature applications is a complex task that involves balancing multiple factors, including thermal stability, oxidation resistance, oil retention, and mechanical performance. 

In many cases, greases that excel in one thermal property may perform poorly in another. For example, a grease with excellent oxidation stability may have a low dropping point, making it unsuitable for very high-temperature applications.

Another challenge is that real-world operating conditions are often more severe than laboratory test conditions. 

Equipment may be subjected to fluctuating temperatures, varying loads, and environmental contaminants such as dust or water, all of which can accelerate grease degradation. 

Therefore, it is important to interpret thermal properties test results in conjunction with field experience and application-specific requirements.

Conclusion

Thermal properties testing is a vital component of grease selection and maintenance for machinery lubrication professionals. 

Understanding how greases respond to elevated temperatures and prolonged exposure to thermal stress is essential for ensuring the reliability and longevity of both the lubricant and the machinery it protects.

Key tests such as the dropping point, oxidation stability, high-temperature life, and evaporation loss provide critical insights into grease performance under high-temperature conditions. 

By interpreting these results in the context of specific application demands, reliability engineers and maintenance professionals can make informed decisions about grease selection and relubrication intervals, ultimately improving equipment reliability and reducing downtime.

As machinery and operational conditions continue to evolve, the importance of accurate and comprehensive thermal properties testing will only grow, ensuring that lubricants keep pace with the demands of modern industrial environments.

Please feel free to share your feedback and thoughts on this topic by using the comment section below or via our contact form to continue the conversation.